OTHER ISSUES

Criminal Justice

Restoring Public Safety and Accountability in Alaska's Criminal Justice System

Alaska's criminal justice system must prioritize the protection of victims, families, and communities above all else. Yet too often, progressive judges and parole board members insert their personal ideology into sentencing and release decisions. In Alaska, the law provides that inmates generally become eligible for discretionary parole after serving just one-third of their active sentence. For sentences longer than two years, they are released on mandatory parole after serving two-thirds of the sentence once good time is applied (one day credited for every two days served). These statutory thresholds were never meant to be suggestions, yet activist decision-makers treat them as flexible guidelines, redefining what a "life sentence" or lengthy term actually means and deciding on their own whether a dangerous offender has served an "adequate" portion of their time.

This judicial activism undermines the rule of law, endangers the public, and erodes trust in our courts. As a candidate for Governor, I believe the definition of a life sentence and the minimum time that must be served before any parole eligibility must be set in clear, binding statute, not left to the discretion of individual judges or board members.

The Problem: Early Release Thresholds Turned Into Loopholes

Because Alaska law allows discretionary parole eligibility at roughly the one-third mark and mandatory parole at the two-thirds mark for most sentences, far too many judges interpret these points as automatic or near-automatic release opportunities. They substitute their personal views on rehabilitation and "second chances" for the plain language of the sentence imposed by the court. The result? Heinous offenders, including those convicted of violent crimes, are released back into our communities long before they have served the full measure of justice, sometimes only to reoffend.

This is not justice, it is ideology over public safety. Parole and release decisions must be governed by fixed statutory timelines that judges cannot override with personal interpretation. Binding language in statute will keep activist ideology out of these life-and-death decisions.

Juvenile Offenders: Extra Leniency Without Legal Basis Endangers the Public

The problem is especially acute with violent juvenile offenders. Too many Alaska judges grant extra leniency, even to those who commit serious harm or violent crimes, based on discretionary factors that have little or no grounding in statute. Public safety is sacrificed when a judge decides a young violent offender "deserves another chance" without clear factual or legal limits. Repeat juvenile offenders who commit assault, robbery, or worse are released back into schools and neighborhoods, putting law-abiding Alaskans, especially other young people, at risk. Our system must protect the public first. Juvenile cases involving violent or harmful conduct should face stricter statutory guidelines, not open-ended judicial discretion that treats public safety as an afterthought.

CourtWatch.US: Shining a Light on Irresponsible Judges

Transparency is the first step toward accountability. That is why the newly created CourtWatch.US platform and others are so important. This citizen-driven tool searches public court records to identify judges whose decisions have led to pretrial releases or parole grants that resulted in defendants failing to appear, being rearrested, or committing new crimes. It does not accuse; it simply publishes the data so Alaskans can see the record.

We need this kind of accountability in Alaska. Every time a judge releases a heinous offender who then reoffends or worse, the public deserves to know. CourtWatch.US proves that ordinary citizens can hold the judiciary accountable when the system fails to police itself. As Governor, I will support expanding and promoting tools like this so voters, victims, and lawmakers can track patterns of leniency and demand change.

My Plan: Statutory Clarity and Real Accountability

To fix this, I will fight for legislation that:

Defines "life sentence" and all parole eligibility thresholds (including the one-third discretionary and two-thirds mandatory points) in clear statutory language that judges cannot override with personal interpretation.

Limits judicial discretion in parole eligibility for the most serious violent crimes.

Establishes stricter statutory guidelines for violent juvenile offenders to protect the public from discretionary releases.

Requires public reporting of parole and release decisions tied to reoffence rates, with data easily accessible to Alaskans.

"Judges serve the law, not the other way around. When they prioritize ideology over victims and community safety, they betray the public trust. It is time to take the politics out of the courtroom and put the law back in control."

— Matt Heilala

Alaskans deserve a criminal justice system that keeps violent criminals behind bars and gives families the peace of mind that justice is actually being served. That is the standard I will fight for as your Governor.

Stand With Matt

Help bring bold, principled leadership to Alaska. Every dollar makes a difference.

Donate to the Campaign